• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Elon Musk: "Having pronouns in a fantasy video game is totally unacceptable". "Stop killing art with woke propaganda"

Status
Not open for further replies.

bundylove

Member
Seriously.
This whole thread is political as fuck.
I got a month ban for posting a cover of a book claiming bipartisan politics but this here flies?

I really dont want to tiptoe around stuff in fear to be banned.

Figured its best not to say anything ever but now a lot of threads are political one way or another.

Some clarification would be nice so i know what topics are accepted to politicises over and what isnt.
 

Fake

Member
In addition to being an extremely average game, it had insufferable writing and characters. This has all been very well documented. Sounds like you have questionable taste.

And if I remember right, the Outer World director did an interview saying that his own game got too woke and that affect sales.


I mean, if even a director of his own game admit that, who am I to point out to someone that can't see as clear as day?
 
Hard to cancel someone who produces fucking nothing and who doesn't own a single business that makes its profit through commerce. He makes his money from government subsidies and wanton corruption. To cancel him you would need to reform the whole government.
I decided to ask Perplexity AI about your post

Please analyze the accuracy of this claim: "Hard to cancel Elon Musk who produces fucking nothing and who doesn't own a single business that makes its profit through commerce. He makes his money from government subsidies and wanton corruption. To cancel him you would need to reform the whole government."​


Sources
Stop funding Elon Musk's anti-democracy power grab - Action Network

actionnetwork.org favicon

actionnetwork

'Ultimate Corporate Corruption': Trump Announces Musk-Led ...

commondreams.org favicon

commondreams

Trump's Elon Musk Appointment Raises Questions About Conflicts ...

newsweek.com favicon

newsweek


sec.gov favicon



citizen.org favicon



endcitizensunited.org favicon



economictimes.indiatimes.com favicon



washingtonpost.com favicon



perplexity.ai favicon


Show all

Answer
The claim that "Elon Musk produces nothing and doesn't own a single business that makes its profit through commerce" is misleading and requires careful analysis.

Business Operations and Revenue Generation​

Musk's Companies: Elon Musk is the CEO of several high-profile companies, including Tesla and SpaceX, both of which generate substantial revenue through commercial activities. Tesla, for instance, is a leading manufacturer of electric vehicles and has earned billions in sales, particularly benefiting from government incentives related to zero-emission vehicles. As of early 2024, Tesla had reportedly made around $9 billion from selling emission credits to other manufacturers
3
. SpaceX, on the other hand, has secured lucrative contracts with NASA and the Department of Defense, amounting to billions for launching satellites and developing spacecraft
3
4
.Government Contracts and Subsidies: While it is true that Musk's companies benefit from government contracts and subsidies, this is a common practice in many industries, particularly those involving advanced technology and infrastructure. For example, SpaceX received nearly $900 million in subsidies from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to expand its Starlink internet service
3
. Critics argue that these arrangements can lead to conflicts of interest, especially when Musk's influence extends into governmental roles aimed at reducing regulations that could benefit his businesses
2
3
.

Claims of Corruption​

The assertion that Musk's wealth stems primarily from "government subsidies and wanton corruption" reflects a broader critique of corporate influence in politics. Reports highlight concerns about Musk's close ties with political figures, particularly with Donald Trump, who has proposed appointing Musk to lead a new government efficiency commission. Critics label this as a potential conflict of interest due to Musk's businesses benefiting from government contracts while he influences regulatory frameworks
2
5
6
.Public Scrutiny: Musk's businesses have faced scrutiny from various federal agencies for alleged misconduct, which some interpret as indicative of systemic issues within his corporate practices
2
8
. This scrutiny raises questions about accountability and the ethical implications of his business operations.

Conclusion​

In summary, while it is accurate to say that Musk leverages government contracts and incentives for his businesses, claiming he produces "nothing" overlooks the significant commercial activities conducted by Tesla and SpaceX. The narrative surrounding corruption and the need for governmental reform reflects ongoing debates about corporate power in politics rather than an objective assessment of Musk's business contributions. Therefore, while there are valid concerns regarding the intersection of his business interests with governmental roles, the claim lacks nuance regarding the actual operations and revenue generation of his companies.

Thanks, AI!
 

KTS2448

Member
First post in 8 years. As a democrat, The "woke" shit would be fine if the progressives weren't literally trying to control speech so much and ban/deplatform anyone who disagrees with them. some of amount of this just giving others respect despite being very different than others. Some of it is little kids trying to get the world to bend the knee to their fetishes. I think a good compromise is eliminate the progressive vocabulary like "pronouns", or whatever but offer many choices for character creation including genders.
 

Buggy Loop

Member
Did you guys ever put your name in chatGPT to see if it brings up anything?

Thank god it had zero on me. Zilch. I prefer it stays that way. Employers would believe anything they find on there as hard truths, no defenses even around that. What's left, change your name?

Worse than facebooks sniffers. ChatGPT is too fast
 
Last edited:

SF Kosmo

Al Jazeera Special Reporter
It still disagrees with you, I wonder if you know that you have less nuance than an Internet chatbot, you're a real life NPC
It just punts to a broader conversation about the decriminalization of political corruption, which is accurate but doesn't really undermine my point. I wasn't calling him a criminal (although he has been accused of fraudulent practices at certain points in his career), but there is something troubling about someone who has made the bulk of their fortune from government money having the kind of access to government influence that he does.

It's weird that "maybe we shouldn't let people bribe public officials for appointments" is seen as some kind of partisan political stance now rather than common sense. Fuck's wrong with everyone?
 
Last edited:

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
I have no love for Elon but he's right. Hearing They/them in dragon age is so retarded. this isnt about trans people. i have nothing but respect for people brave enough to go through surgery and cut their dicks off. id gladly call them she. they have earned it and im not an asshole. but they? gtfo.

I used to argue with one of my friends about how this pronoun shit will never get mainstream enough so that it comes to my work. Until it did last year. time proved him right, it took around 6 years, but he was right. And it was because of people like me who stuck our heads in the sand and let things get worse.

Now we cant afford to do the same because its pronouns today and it will be drag queens tomorrow. you give them an inch. they will take a mile.
 
Last edited:

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
First post in 8 years. As a democrat, The "woke" shit would be fine if the progressives weren't literally trying to control speech so much and ban/deplatform anyone who disagrees with them. some of amount of this just giving others respect despite being very different than others. Some of it is little kids trying to get the world to bend the knee to their fetishes. I think a good compromise is eliminate the progressive vocabulary like "pronouns", or whatever but offer many choices for character creation including genders.
People will naturally push back against any ideology they don't want to submit to. Submission to ideology results in the partial loss of personal identity, and potentially sweeping changes to culture.

Yes, it's just a small element in a video game and it's not that serious--but on some level it is that serious. A lot of people just want things to go back to normal.
 

GeoramA

Member
I really don't get why western devs keep sabotaging their games like this. Adding pronouns adds nothing and will only (rightfully) piss a lot of people off.
 

TintoConCasera

I bought a sex doll, but I keep it inflated 100% of the time and use it like a regular wife
I really don't get why western devs keep sabotaging their games like this. Adding pronouns adds nothing and will only (rightfully) piss a lot of people off.
Hey at the very least it provides some fuel for online conversation and social apps rage which I guess turns out to be free marketing in the end.

But yeah aside from that I think it's a very dumb thing to add.
 

Buggy Loop

Member
People will naturally push back against any ideology they don't want to submit to. Submission to ideology results in the partial loss of personal identity, and potentially sweeping changes to culture.

Yes, it's just a small element in a video game and it's not that serious--but on some level it is that serious. A lot of people just want things to go back to normal.

I hate the pronouns, it doesn't even make any fucking sense in my native language, it's always (so far) seem to be an issue when I deal with Americans. I'm sure there's a nutjob at an university that is working overtime to make the pronouns stick in my language but so far, hasn't hit any form of open media, at least I'm not aware of them.

But Elon Musk ain't nowhere near normal. He's pro Transhumanism. Sounds cool and sci-fi, so its all fine I guess. But these cultural "wars" will be cute in comparison to the social clash of peoples being mind chipped or body heavily modified to whatever they want (including sexually of course). The ethics behind it all and the blood that will be spilled over these new issues will make the current situation pale in comparison. Could even result in war. Musk is triggered from his own kin being trans, but he would without a doubt be for anyone installing a 20 inch metallic dick, if the money came his way.

Will probably die before I see the extent of it, but Musk certainly ain't aiming for going back to normal. "Classical" humans will be a relic of the past.
 

shamoomoo

Member
First off, I have a trans woman as a roommate so you don't need to tell me about lgbtq. Second off you're completely missing the point.
Which is what? The highlighted portion makes it seem like a Japanese LGBTQ person who makes games or Japanese gaming can't pursue a similar representation as the West Independent of how it's occurring in the U.S.
 

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
I hate the pronouns, it doesn't even make any fucking sense in my native language, it's always (so far) seem to be an issue when I deal with Americans. I'm sure there's a nutjob at an university that is working overtime to make the pronouns stick in my language but so far, hasn't hit any form of open media, at least I'm not aware of them.

But Elon Musk ain't nowhere near normal. He's pro Transhumanism. Sounds cool and sci-fi, so its all fine I guess. But these cultural "wars" will be cute in comparison to the social clash of peoples being mind chipped or body heavily modified to whatever they want (including sexually of course). The ethics behind it all and the blood that will be spilled over these new issues will make the current situation pale in comparison. Could even result in war. Musk is triggered from his own kin being trans, but he would without a doubt be for anyone installing a 20 inch metallic dick, if the money came his way.

Will probably die before I see the extent of it, but Musk certainly ain't aiming for going back to normal. "Classical" humans will be a relic of the past.
Definitely serious concerns with transhumanism, I agree, but the early stages of neuralink-type tech will be a miracle to people with paralysis and other serious conditions. Preventing a dystopian cyberpunk outcome, well, we can try to figure out later.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Definitely serious concerns with transhumanism, I agree, but the early stages of neuralink-type tech will be a miracle to people with paralysis and other serious conditions. Preventing a dystopian cyberpunk outcome, well, we can try to figure out later.

Yeah but I hope it's tested to hell and back before public deployment. I can see scenarios where tech like that can backfire too unfortunately.
 
I really don't get why western devs keep sabotaging their games like this. Adding pronouns adds nothing and will only (rightfully) piss a lot of people off.
The games started dev 3-5 years ago in order to release today

This is a consequence of chasing cultural trends that have recently changed

It's also a consequence of the Western games industry being heavily infected by a woke mind virus pandemic
 

Kdad

Member
People will naturally push back against any ideology they don't want to submit to. Submission to ideology results in the partial loss of personal identity, and potentially sweeping changes to culture.

Yes, it's just a small element in a video game and it's not that serious--but on some level it is that serious. A lot of people just want things to go back to normal.
There is no 'normal'. How far would you like to go back?
When we are there, what will you say to those that think it isnt 'going back' far enough and still isn't 'normal' for them?
What happens to your opinion of what is 'normal' when there are folks pushing to go further than you want to.
You'll have the EXACT same 'issue' you have now.
Humanity and society evolve, those that do not tend to be left behind after awhile.
 
Last edited:

Bashtee

Member
Really? I've been in this game over 30yrs worked on lots of sites all and worked with lots of diverse teams and I've never once had to think what gender is this person, it simply doesn't exist outside of woke AF media firms and their HR/Marketing departments, everyone else.. it's all men and women and that's what's infuriating about this whole thing, trans people in ordinary life are like fucking unicorns we all know they exist but we never encounter them day to day yet I have to wear a fucking unicorn badge, play a fucking unicorn and if I don't like it, I'm the bigot!?!?
No fucking clue what you are on about, but sometimes it’s impossible to know the gender of a person based on their name alone, especially if they are from a different region. Pronouns help, because then I don’t have to lookup the person or their name.
 

YOU PC BRO?!

Gold Member
I have a solution…

Make Saudi mode available in every game… let us toggle that woke! Fair compromise I’d say.

O’ and while we are on the subject… would a feminism toggle be too much to ask? I demand a Tate mode immediately!!!
 

Bernardougf

Member
There is no 'normal'. How far would you like to go back?
When we are there, what will you say to those that think it isnt 'going back' far enough and isn't still isn't 'normal' for them?
What happens to your opinion of normal when there are folks pushing to go further than you want to.
You'll have the EXACT same 'issue' you have now.
Humanity and society evolve, those that do not tend to be left behind after awhile.
Lol I can garantee buddy for the majority of the world that is a Normal on this subjects.. and probably is not what you and your 1% bubble think it should be
 

Raven117

Member
First post in 8 years. As a democrat, The "woke" shit would be fine if the progressives weren't literally trying to control speech so much and ban/deplatform anyone who disagrees with them. some of amount of this just giving others respect despite being very different than others. Some of it is little kids trying to get the world to bend the knee to their fetishes. I think a good compromise is eliminate the progressive vocabulary like "pronouns", or whatever but offer many choices for character creation including genders.
Yup. But the focus is on control… not the “wokeness” it pretends to champion.

Wokeness is just their avenue of choice. These same type of people were/are the intolerant evangelical right.
 
the problem is not the fantasy words being used in video games, the issue is changing old games to fit a new generation of gamers which doesnt exist, it totally fine to make new game with all the fantasy poltical correct words, just dont use it on games that builds its fan base before your feelings got hurt.
 

Kdad

Member
"Normal" becomes a way to distinguish between the acceptable and the deviant, often serving the interests of those in authority. Funny those championing 'freedom of speech' also push 'Normal', which limits speech and serves only those in authority.
 

Three

Member
Lol I can garantee buddy for the majority of the world that is a Normal on this subjects.. and probably is not what you and your 1% bubble think it should be
He's making a statement that "normal" itself doesn't exist and what was considered normal before is no longer normal by questioning how far back this normal would be for a given individual. In the past it was "normal" to own slaves. In the past it was normal for women not to vote. Would those be considered "normal" today?
 
Last edited:
Again, it is ponderous devs include things to solely pander and signal to a small fraction of a small fraction of the total gaming audience. And if you know the inclusion will turn off a sizeable portion... it makes no sense unless it is solely for the vanity of a creative lead. How many new consumers do you get verses how many do you lose by this one added on virtue signal?

I'll never understand why they shoehorn this shit in when it doesn't even make sense to do so in the grander context of their game, world, etc. Even if said doesn't flop, but breaks even... is it worth it to alienate a large portion of your consumer base? I do not understand the business sense behind these moves,
 
Last edited:

Bernardougf

Member
He's making a statement that "normal" itself doesn't exist and what was considered normal before is no longer normal and how far back this normal would be. In the past it was "normal" to own slaves. In the past it was normal for women not to vote. Would those be considered "normal" today?
Sorry Normal definitely exists .... you may disagree and theres nothing I can do.
 

kruis

Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
People will naturally push back against any ideology they don't want to submit to. Submission to ideology results in the partial loss of personal identity, and potentially sweeping changes to culture.

Exactly, it's submission to ideology. At least with books, games and films you can chose to spend your money elsewhere, but it's a different matter when you're forced to go along with the gender pronoun thing even if you find non binary pronouns and the idea there are dozens upon dozens of gender identities ridiculous. And its downright evil to push this ideology on impressionable children who haven't yet figured out who they are.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom