At this point, we're really derailing a thread.
But I'll bite one last time.
First of all, I don't blame brave people of Belarus, nor do I blame anyone who fought and lost against dictatorship because I happen to know what's it's like. The fact that you can't empathize with that is really telling.
I empathize with the Belarussians. Not with the Russians.
At least the Belarussians did make a proper attempt to free themselves. But that effort was curbed by the Russians.
Secondly, painting 1917 russian revolution as a positive is rich, the regime that followed is responsible for too many horrors, including the kgb, fsb and putin.
The 1917 revolution succeeded for a while. you might remember that the communist only received a small portion of the votes.
Kerensky formed a democratic government, but he also made several mistakes, such as continuing to push for the army to attack, when the soldiers just wanted to defend.
And he managed to insult and alienate a few generals, that when the communists attacked the capital, turned their backs on him.
The communists took power by violence, after the revolution and after the first elections. Of course, that when in power, they claimed they had done the whole thing by themselves.
You might also want to remember that many Russians (white) fought against the Reds, to restore democratic rule. The USA even sent a few battalions to Russia to help the Whites.
But the Communists won, the revolution failed and Russia went to another autocratic regime.
Curious that you would associate Putin with the communists, when he openly criticizes the USSR and the Communist party. And while he praises Alexandre III and references Ivan Ilyin.
In case you haven't noticed, Putin is ideologically closer to fascism. Not to communism.
The similarity is that both systems are autocratic and use violence and repression to control the people.
Thirdly, about current russians lacking the spirit. It's incredibly frustrating seeing people who didn't have to fight for their own freedoms, giving you history lessons and throwing judgements at you for not doing it correctly. I'd like to see you try. We've been at it since 2010s and we lost. Just consider this, it's possible to do everything you could've done and still lose. The fact that western democracies continued engorging putin's regime with money, even after 2014, didn't help. The fact that western democracies sold riot gear to russian riot police (omon) didn't help either, we've been beaten into submission by the batons of eu making.
Now to my point. I'm not conflating protest with revolution attempts. The point is, protests barely achieve anything in democracies and they absolutely do not work in authoritarian regime. With the current technology the revolution is pretty much impossible. putin and his cronies seem to have learned all the necessary lessons from history to keep himself in power. Revolutions happen
All democratic countries had to fight for their freedoms. Some started a couple of centuries ago, so for people lacking historical knowledge, it might seem like they didn't earn it.
My country fought for it and got it, less than half a century ago.
Russia had a great opportunity at a change in regime in the 90s, when the Communist regime fell.
Russians could have had democracy and freedom. For a while it really seemed like you would manage to get it.
But somehow Russians managed to grab defeat from the jaws of victory and allowed a KGB agent to become the next dictator.
And now, my turn to cast a little bit of judgement on you. Where's the western spirit? Are you going to finally get a clue and realize putin is a world threat, not just some far-away problem you can continue to ignore? Are you going to provide everything Ukraine needs to win? Are you going to stand with them until they regain control of all their territories including Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk? Or are your principles that fickle? Because I'm not so sure anymore. You don't seem to be the same west capable of uniting against a common enemy. You seem to be too busy laughing at our expense and pretending the threat will go away on its own if you just keep your eyes closed for long enough.
Rather than ridiculing the hero who died twice opposing putin, do something useful and donate to Ukraine and keep doing that until they win.
And in case you haven't noticed, a lot of people in this thread, including me, have said that the west is not doing enough to help Ukraine. And that all territories must be retaken. We have been saying it for a long time.
So don't pretend that you have some special moral high ground.
You might consider Navalny a hero. A lot of people in the west don't.
But admittedly, it doesn't matter what the people in the west think about him.
More important, is what are the Russians going to do about it? And the answer is to put some flowers in a memorial and walk away.
Russians won't do anything more. They will just go back to being serfs under Putin.