• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree | Review Thread

What Scores do you think Shadow of the Erdtree will get?

  • 0-65%

    Votes: 3 1.8%
  • 66-69%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 70-74%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 75-79%

    Votes: 1 0.6%
  • 80-84%

    Votes: 3 1.8%
  • 85-89%

    Votes: 25 15.2%
  • 90-94%

    Votes: 94 57.0%
  • 95-100%

    Votes: 39 23.6%

  • Total voters
    165
  • Poll closed .

Gaiff

SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
The PS5 version has been updated to have a 60fps performance mode, you are literally just gimping your graphical experience playing the PS4 version on PS5 now
I'm not sure if my tv has vrr, I'll take a look?



Oh really? Didn't heard about the patch, I found the game look pretty good but loading sent me back in the old pre SSD days lol
The PS5 and Series X versions always had a performance mode. It was just very unstable with screen tearing and hiccups. It’s been updated a few times but the most stable way to play on consoles is still the PS4 version running on a PS5. Almost a locked 60.
 

Caio

Member
So I pressed onward past Mohg and went to the Subterranean Shunning Grounds, which I skipped on my first playthrough. That place is a fucking joke. Super tough enemies and almost a labyrinth in places. It's awesome though, reminds me of the areas in Dark Souls a bit.
I love this Area, as you said, it's a labyrinth, and you can unlock a particular ending, if you go very "deeply". I also loved the "parkour"...when you go down and down...and find the strongest shield in the game.
I love this Game, tomorrow cannot come soon enough.
 

EMR

Member
It's interesting that no one is complaining about the awful stutter/judder problem on PS5 (been there for 2,5 years). Of course FS hasn't fixed it.
 
Last edited:
I love this Area, as you said, it's a labyrinth, and you can unlock a particular ending, if you go very "deeply". I also loved the "parkour"...when you go down and down...and find the strongest shield in the game.
I love this Game, tomorrow cannot come soon enough.
I've not wrapped up the area yet, but my god the fucking revenant in the sewer.. I can't beat it at level 118, its so dark in there and it moves so fucking fast lol.

I got to the spiral staircase but one of the big dudes in the room stole my lunch money and kicked my ass. Gonna upgrade my moonveil to +10 tonight and try again.
 

tommib

Gold Member
I'm not sure if my tv has vrr, I'll take a look?



Oh really? Didn't heard about the patch, I found the game look pretty good but loading sent me back in the old pre SSD days lol
Yeah. The loading on PS5 is almost instantaneous. I wouldn’t trade that for locked blurry locked 60 and long loading times.
 

tommib

Gold Member
I love this Area, as you said, it's a labyrinth, and you can unlock a particular ending, if you go very "deeply". I also loved the "parkour"...when you go down and down...and find the strongest shield in the game.
I love this Game, tomorrow cannot come soon enough.
Is this there where you also get a specific scar and burn? I loved finding that all by myself. Those are the From moments I truly worship. You keep going and going thinking you’re going nowhere and all of a sudden some fucked nightmarish miracle happens.
 
Last edited:

Caio

Member
I've not wrapped up the area yet, but my god the fucking revenant in the sewer.. I can't beat it at level 118, its so dark in there and it moves so fucking fast lol.

I got to the spiral staircase but one of the big dudes in the room stole my lunch money and kicked my ass. Gonna upgrade my moonveil to +10 tonight and try again.
Not an easy place, with dark areas and insidious enemies, some labyrinth, very intriguing, some hidden passages, a lot to discover. Upgrade your weapon and kill them all :D
 
It's interesting that no one is complaining about the awful stutter/judder problem on PS5 (been there for 2,5 years). Of course FS hasn't fixed it.
I do believe there was a patch long ago that smoothed everything out. I don't remember if it was a VRR patch but once that hit I was full ps5 version on my LG. It's perfectly fine at 60 fps now.
 

Luipadre

Gold Member
I do believe there was a patch long ago that smoothed everything out. I don't remember if it was a VRR patch but once that hit I was full ps5 version on my LG. It's perfectly fine at 60 fps now.

No, its still as shit as ever. Just go outside limgrave and the judder starts. There are a lots of areas still where the game judders and stutters, VRR doesnt do shit
 

Caio

Member
Is this there where you also get a specific scar and burn? I loved finding that all by myself. Those are the From moments I truly worship. You keep going and going thinking you’re going nowhere and all of a sudden some fucked nightmarish miracle happens.
On my first run, I believed to have discovered everything about that big area. In reality, a lot was missing LOL
I needed a second run to understand there was areas where I didn't even go, I missed a Big Boss, the strongest shield of the Game, and other things, like another "ending of the Game", you should see my face when I discovered that :D
 

tommib

Gold Member
On my first run, I believed to have discovered everything about that big area. In reality, a lot was missing LOL
I needed a second run to understand there was areas where I didn't even go, I missed a Big Boss, the strongest shield of the Game, and other things, like another "ending of the Game", you should see my face when I discovered that :D
It’s the moment I remember the most. Being in the deepest and darkest bowels of the earth getting burned and scarred by a demonic hand.

Completely unforgettable.

That’s why I keep saying From has in them the capacity to make the best survival horror game of all time.
 
Last edited:

Caio

Member
It’s the moment I remember the most. Being in the deepest and darkest bowels of the earth getting burned and scarred by a demonic hand.

Completely unforgettable.

That’s why I keep saying From has in them the capacity to make the best survival horror game of all time.
Exactly, that was a truly WOW moment for me, comparable to when I found the presents under the Christmas tree for the first time, convinced that Santa Claus had brought them to me. I love FROM, with passion, their art and level design.
 

Agent_4Seven

Tears of Nintendo
Is it harder than the Main Game or the same level?
Uranus better be ready:messenger_bicep:

Legit lmao

My buddy just beat Elden Beast two days ago after failing for two years. Two days later, Torrent.
It took me a couple of years of tries to beat goddamn Darkeater Midir and finally finish Dark Souls III's final DLC. I fuckin' hate this motherfucker. It's not hard or challenging at all, it's just extremely tedious, annoying and long af endurance run and test of your fuckin' patience.
 

Madflavor

Member
I pretty much beat everything but stopped after killing Gideon. Going Str/Holy with Maliketh's Black Blade. Here's hoping Holy is actually good this time around.

I do really love the look of Light Greatswords though. Too many games have one handed swords and then big ass buster swords, but not just regular ass two handed swords like what Aragorn wielded.
 

Agent_4Seven

Tears of Nintendo
That's great news. Now if only they would add DLSS...
And Photo Mode.

laughing-dog-dog.gif
 
Last edited:

Arsic

Loves his juicy stink trail scent
yZu8C53.png


The countdown on Steam has been consistent during today. It could be wrong though. We'll see soon.
Fuck. Is this one of those gotta change my computer's time zone clock?

I'm a retard. I thought we would be playing now. :(
 

Agent_4Seven

Tears of Nintendo
Just launched the main game to get to the location and start DLC in a few hours...

Goddam, the game has a massive pop in a LOD issues on PC. Is there a mod or something which can fix that?
 
Last edited:

Agent_4Seven

Tears of Nintendo
I won't be online when SOTE launches (which is 1:00 at night here) and I don't want to keep y'all waiting for 9 to 10 hrs, so... OT is LIVE (designed for the dark theme and 4K monitors as always) :messenger_relieved:
 

SSfox

Member
After copiying PS5 game from HDD to SSD i got an auto 16 GB DLC, guess it's dlc? (was confusing cause i heard it's 6gb on PC)


Yeah. The loading on PS5 is almost instantaneous. I wouldn’t trade that for locked blurry locked 60 and long loading times.
I took your advice you're right my friend. I ended going going PS5 and try it a bit, there's bit frame moosh moosh but it's not that big deal, picture is bit better and most importantly loading are much faster, which is big game changer in a game like where we're gonna die a lot in our first run lol
 

Dynasty8

Member
Eurogamer is one of the few non-biased, trusted media outlets, so them giving it a 3/5 is rather concerning.

Pretty sure you're trolling, but yeah for anyone who isn't aware...Eurogamer, Polygon, Wired and especially Kotaku should never, ever, EVER be taken seriously. They don't do reviews, they do rants.
 
Top Bottom