Hardensoul
Member
We here are in a bubble not seeing how bad inflation and bad economy is affecting the everyday people. Our hobby is pretty expensive. This NPD is looking like proof of that!
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Circana (NPD) November 2023: #1 COD MWIII #2 Spider-Man 2 #3 Hogwarts Legacy; PS5 #1 Units + Revenue, XBS #2 Units + Revenue
- Thread starter Thick Thighs Save Lives
- Start date
- Sales-Age
mayham2199
Member
If a brand new exclusive from Bethesda doesn’t move the needle is a new subscription service going to entice people? For a game they can keep getting on the console they already own and community/friends they’ve made.
Deerock71
Member
Well, it doen't seem like things have gone Microsoft's way in this space, but they're sure as shit going to make another push after this.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
The problem is, starfield didn't land where it needed to. Many people enjoy it massively, but it ended up being more of a death Stranding type game, divisive but loved by some, hated by others. Starfield needed to be a god of war level game, or skyrim, or fallout 3...not a death Stranding divisive game with glaring issues.
Last edited:
Unknown Soldier
Member
And HD DVD, and Internet Explorer, and Bing, and uh
SneakersSO
Member
Absolutely not, nor would he have ever. In the world of a megacorp like MS, to say that you must expand your audience is a form of admitting failure, depending on the context of when you do it in.
Unknown Soldier
Member
Bro gaming has long been one of the cheapest hobbies, you should try pricing out a new bicycle or something one of these days. Go to your local sporting goods store and see how much stuff costs, meanwhile game consoles and games haven't gone up in price over for over 20 years even though the value of the US Dollar has halved in that time
SneakersSO
Member
We've firmly reached the point where typical economic factors, like value perception either on price or usefulness, are no longer applying to this product. If this is how its doing in its strongest region, every region outside of NA is tanking and hard. Price cuts aren't helping, a solid showing all year on SW didn't help either. Sales for their console will basically be flatlining outside of NA once we hit January. Xbox is cooked. Never seen a tech product recover from this.
Unknown Soldier
Member
It's like watching the final death of Windows Phone again. Or HD DVD. Or Zune. Or Internet Explorer.
Microsoft's problem is they only know how to throw money at problems and then they are out of ideas. Well, they threw $70 billion at acquiring ABK, what's the next step in your master plan MS?
Compared to Hi-Fi hobby, its a pittance.
tommib
Gold Member
Delusional take. Starfield has nowhere near the cult potential of Death Stranding which is absolutely loved by the PC gaming community:
Thirty7ven
Banned
Xbox management should've put more thought into what kind of audience they wanted to appeal to, and what type of messaging it would take to reach that audience. That they seemed to have settled on uneducated sounding idiots, who look like low rent MCU
The brand management is woeful top to bottom. But congrats the Xbox logo will now appear on Call of Duty games, that will change everything.
The Last One
Member
Still sounds expensive.
jm89
Member
ShadowkillXNA
Member
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
This includes 100% parity. Xbox has submitted in court that COD will be exactly the same on both Xbox and PS - both in terms of content and the timing/availability of said content.
The only thing that will change is that Xbox will showcase the next COD games in their Showcases, instead of Sony.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Xbox has dug its own grave with these discounts.
As the consoles are still available and not selling at $349 and £399, how will they increase their price back to the MSRP of $500?
If they revert the price, it won't sell. If they decrease it any further to increase sales, they will have to eat even more loss. There is no way out. Seems very reminiscent of Sega. and Dreamcast -- at least the console pricing structure.
Unknown?
Member
And they had the same problem last gen with Xbox One. The only difference is that they were able to sell consoles during the discount back then but they still tanked until the next deep discount. Now the discounts barely even work.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Absolutely great point, but there is something to be said that there is 5 times as many reviews for Starfield as Death Stranding and death stranding launched much later on PC I believe, where it was a known QTY what the game was. I think this would have an impact on who picked up the game and were aware of what they were getting into. Meaning, those that bought it probably had a good idea that it was a game that interested them...if that makes sense.Delusional take. Starfield has nowhere near the cult potential of Death Stranding which is absolutely loved by the PC gaming community:
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
Xbox numbers are not good. They are down a large amount from last year and last gen.
Last edited:
Astray
Member
Small experiment so might not be super indicative of anything, but I went on Camelcamelcamel and searched for the pricing history of the Zune HD 32GB on Amazon.
Filtering only for Amazon's pricing without 3rd parties (because they would have a direct relationship with Microsoft, and thus would have "officially mandated" price changes), this yields quite the interesting timeline:
Launch date of the Zune HD 32GB: September 15, 2009 (MSRP = $269.00).
Lowest Amazon price tag: $169.00 (posted on March 7 2011), which is a ~%37 discount.
Microsoft announces that they are stopping new Zune model development on March 15 2011 (almost exactly a week after the biggest discount), and then announces the complete discontinuation of the Zune brand after 7 more months, in October 2011.
Right now, Microsoft is discounting the Series S|X very heavily, with the S going as low as $150 (%50 discount), and the X going as low as $350 on Amazon (%30 discount, maybe more because I'm seeing game bundles sold at the exact same price). You will also note little to no marketing during the holiday season, apart from social media posts.
Make no mistake, this is an absolute fire sale, and if my inferences are correct that there's a pattern there, I think we might indeed be watching the beginning of the end of home console wars as a concept.
Filtering only for Amazon's pricing without 3rd parties (because they would have a direct relationship with Microsoft, and thus would have "officially mandated" price changes), this yields quite the interesting timeline:
Launch date of the Zune HD 32GB: September 15, 2009 (MSRP = $269.00).
Lowest Amazon price tag: $169.00 (posted on March 7 2011), which is a ~%37 discount.
Microsoft announces that they are stopping new Zune model development on March 15 2011 (almost exactly a week after the biggest discount), and then announces the complete discontinuation of the Zune brand after 7 more months, in October 2011.
Right now, Microsoft is discounting the Series S|X very heavily, with the S going as low as $150 (%50 discount), and the X going as low as $350 on Amazon (%30 discount, maybe more because I'm seeing game bundles sold at the exact same price). You will also note little to no marketing during the holiday season, apart from social media posts.
Make no mistake, this is an absolute fire sale, and if my inferences are correct that there's a pattern there, I think we might indeed be watching the beginning of the end of home console wars as a concept.
Last edited:
SportsFan581
Member
I had a feeling that the units would have to be down on the Xbox side even with the discounts, just because they seem to have shifted focus to the XSX this year where last year they were focusing a lot more on pushing XSS. Even at $350 that's a $100 bump in dollars per unit over the $250 XSS they were putting front and center last year. Still think it was a good move though, they needed to try and get more XSX units out.
@
Astray
, I think you might need to investigate a bit more. MS loves to fire sale consoles at the holidays, when PS4 was still at $250 they'd have the X1 out there at $150-$160, it's what they do.
Last edited:
PropellerEar
Member
Profit seeking company wants to sell their product at a huge loss because its enjoyable.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
I think I've said it...but I'll say it again. If December ain't huge for xbox...Philly boy gonna be sweating!
MasterCornholio
Member
Bigger than November?
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Not only bigger than November, they NEED to hit 1million units sold in N/A.
Unknown?
Member
I can guarantee they won't hit that. They may do better slightly but the deals were too late to make a big difference.
The Last One
Member
Their november's numbers were terrible all around. They need to at least do better in December.
MasterCornholio
Member
Isn't November historically the stronger month for consoles?
The Last One
Member
But they were so bad that maybe they can do a little better in December with all the price cuts.
demigod
Member
No not always. I’ve seen some December being higher.
Woopah
Member
It very much depends on how strong the Black Friday deals are. This year, I expect all three platforms to do better in December than November.
SportsFan581
Member
Profit seeking company wants to sell their product at a huge loss because its enjoyable.
Someone there definitely thinks its worth taking a hit to try and get more systems out the door. Probably not something the number crunchers are all that happy with, but something they do repeatedly regardless (every generation, almost every holiday outside of launch years). LOL Absolutely not a new thing from them.
Context is important.
Last edited:
demigod
Member
Thank you captain obvious welfare. MS are known for channel stuffing.
Then you have 2
s telling me i don’t know what i’m talking about when every retailer and their grandma are having fire sales on the xbox series.
Killjoy-NL
Gold Member
All you have to do is look back at the topics pre-release, with all the Xbox fans cheering about a serious Tflop difference between PS5 and Series X and who to this day claim that Xbox is doing fine.
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Thank you captain obvious welfare. MS are known for channel stuffing.
Then you have 2
Welfare has an audience that doesn't know what you know though.
nowhat
Gold Member
You know, I belong in a minority. A minority that is is constantly being ridiculed, but we are really right. That being invert-Y.Thank you captain obvious welfare. MS are known for channel stuffing.
Then you have 2
But you light-theme users should face involuntary commitment.
(try having an OLED laptop - the light, it burns us!)
Last edited:
demigod
Member
MasterCornholio
Member
Saw this on resetera. Tweet is gone now
I guess it's because consumers will just expect a lower price point in the future. Thus it could harm sales a lot once the price goes back up.
Woopah
Member
That was the fate suffered by the GameCube.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
Horseganador
Member
I am quite curious about the December sales in the USA, it is a very big price difference between PS5 and SX (100-150$), and what Mat says is nothing that is not known, now MS must choose between maintaining prices and selling little at a loss a lot of money or go back to the original price and sink the console permanently.
Last edited:
Dick Jones
Gold Member
Yes Welfare, 2024 will be a year of all time...every year is a year of all time.
StealthGoblin
Banned
I can't think of a reasonable way in which Microsoft can turn things around for the Xbox Series.
The whispers of them going next gen early would basically prove that.
The whispers of them going next gen early would basically prove that.
Lucifers Beard
Member
MWIII as the best selling game? No surprise but I'm hoping more people see it for the dumpster fire it is. What a shit show that franchise has become over the last couple games.
Tsaki
Member
It definitely had an effect since its sales are quite lower than MW2